Voice of the unheard & home to the homeless
Front Page  ŕ—»ž
«Š„š»— «Šŕ«„
 Latest News
 Articles and Analysies
 Press Releases
 Photo Gallery
 About Sudan
  Sudanese Music
  Sudanese Links
  Discussion Board
  2006 News Archives
  2006 Articles Archives
  2006 Press R.Archives
  2005 News Archives
  2005 Articles Archives
  2005 Press R.Archives
  PC&Internet Forum
  Poll System
  Tell A Friend
  Upload Your Picture
  Contact Us


Articles and Analysies «Š’›Õ… «Šŕ—»Ū… Last Updated: Mar 5, 2010 - 8:26:47 PM

Is Sudanís CPA Being Dishonored? By Jimmy Mulla President Voices for Sudan

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Is Sudanís CPA Being Dishonored?


By Jimmy Mulla


President Voices for Sudan




In his book Southern Sudan: Too Many Agreements Dishonored, Abel Alier, Sudanís former first Vice-President and President of the Regional Government in South Sudan after the 1972 peace agreement, wrote that the root cause of the long conflict between the central government and South Sudan is that many agreements between Khartoum and the people of South Sudan have been dishonored.  Indeed, dating back to before the Addis Ababa agreement that ended the 1955-1972 North-South war, political establishments in Khartoum have resorted to all kinds of tactics to undermine agreement after agreement, including political, economic, diplomatic and military force, resulting in the cycle of violence that has persisted over five decades.


In 1955 just as Sudan was about to gain independence, a civil war erupted in the Southern part of the country that was temporarily settled in 1972 before it resumed and re-ignited in 1983. The second round of conflict lasted for over two decades until the Government of Sudan and the Sudan Peopleís Liberation Movement/Army (SPLM/A) signed the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) in January 2005.


The question that comes to mind is whether after five years, Sudanís 2005 Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) has become one too many agreements dishonored. Sudanís 1972 Addis Ababa Agreement survived for ten years before it was abrogated by Jaafar Nimeiri , sparking the resumption of a second round of the North-South war, which later engulfed the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile, and spread to Eastern Sudan.


Negotiated over a two-year period, the structure of the CPA was strongly influenced by the fear of past dishonored agreements. In an attempt to safeguard the agreement and avoid a repetition of past mishaps, with the help of international experts some institutional measures were incorporated in the CPA to ensure its full implementation. The document outlined protocols for a number of issues, including power-sharing, wealth-sharing, security arrangements, and resolutions of conflicts in Abyei, Southern Kordofan and Blue Nile States. The Machakos Protocol, a main component of the agreement, established a six-year interim period during which the southern Sudanese will have the right to govern affairs in their region and participate equitably in the national government.


Among other measures adopted were the formation of several commissions, and allowing two separate armies to co-exist with small integrated units under the security arrangements. With the hope that these measures would withstand the challenges of time, a seal bearing the phrase, ďUnity is to be made attractiveĒ was then affixed to the CPA.


However, the turn of events that followed the signing of the agreement raises serious doubts as to whether the CPA will withstand the challenge of time.


In his report 19 months after the signing of the peace agreement, United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan strongly criticized the government of Sudan on the slow pace of implementation of the peace agreement, noting that several important parts of the agreement had fallen well behind schedule, and that there had been little progress made towards disarming fighters or establishing a human rights commission. A commission set up to share Sudan's oil revenue was not functioning properly, and the north denied the UN access to the extremely contentious region of Abyei.


Since the signing of the CPA, serious concerns have been raised about violations, and contrary to expectations, to date every measure put in place to ensure flawless implementation of the agreement has yielded dismal results.


On power sharing, for example, the Government of National Unity (GNU) that was formed was supposed to be a decentralized system of government, granting more power to individual states. Instead Khartoum retained monopoly of power.   From the very start, Sudanís ruling National Congress Party rejected outright the idea of sharing ministerial positions equally with the Sudan Peopleís Liberation Movement (SPLM), clinging to both the Ministries of Finance, and Energy and Mining. On commissions, such as the Abyei Commission Boundaries Commission (ABC), the commission heard testimony from all stakeholders and issues ruling on the Abyei boundary, but the Government in Khartoum rejects the ruling, claiming the ABC overstepped its mandate.


Deadlock with Khartoum over Abyei's administration and other issues, the SPLM announced on October 11, 2007 that it was boycotting the GNU, accusing the north of violating the terms of the 2005 peace deal. The SPLM says it was forced to suspend its two-year-long participation in Sudan's national unity government because of what it described as Khartoumís failure to fully implement key elements of the CPA.


In May 2008 clashes in the oil rich region of Abyei claimed many innocent lives, driving 50,000 people from their homes and the town was burned down. In June 2008, an agreement was reached to hand the issue over to a specially convened tribunal sitting at the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague, whose decision would be binding on both parties. The court issued its ruling, which was accepted by both sides but has yet to be implemented.


Additional examples of mishaps in the CPA implementation process include the North-South border demarcation remaining largely unresolved, disputes over wealth sharing, of late the census results, difficulties in drafting and enactment of laws, and a contentious electoral process, wherein key figures of the opposition were detained by security forces.


It is to be recalled that as the North-South peace deal was putting an end to one conflict, another conflict erupted in Darfur in February 2003 as the Government of Sudan (GoS) turned attention to opposition groups from the Sudan Liberation Movement/Army (SLM/A) and the Justice and Equality Movement (JEM). In a similar fashion, following months of negotiation and with pressure from the international community, the government of Sudan and a faction of the SLM/A signed Darfur Peace Agreement (DPA) in Abuja in May 2006.


In addition to the 2005 CPA and the 2006 DPA, the Government of Sudan signed the Eastern Sudan Peace Agreement (ESPA) with the Eastern Front in October 2006 in Eritreaís capital, Asmara, ending a decade-long conflict in the eastern part of the country. These agreements were supposed to form the basis of the countryís transformation into a new era of peace. Unfortunately, the DPA deal did not succeed in bringing peace and stability to the people of Darfur and ESPA did not address the grievances in the east.


Apart from key members from these groups being appointed to government positions, none of the agreementsí other provisions have been implemented, thereby also relegating the DPA and ESPA to the list of too many agreements dishonored. Undoubtedly, the current preliminary framework peace between the government of Sudan and Justice and Equality Movement signed in Doha will suffer a similar fate.


Overall, Khartoum has been meticulously calculating and relentless in employing old habits to maintain predominance at all costs.   It remains to be seen whether the upcoming elections will provide a lucky break in this trend, despite the fact that so far, the CPA Ė as with all other previous peace agreements Ė has failed to live up to expectations.


Nevertheless, while some consider that the CPA has already failed, others consider the ultimate test for the CPA to be the referendum in 2011, in which Southern Sudanese will determine whether they want to secede, or remain part of the larger Sudan. Time may have run out on ďmaking unity attractiveĒ, and on January 9, during the fifth anniversary celebration of the signing of the CPA, Sudanís ruling head of State publicly stated that should South Sudan vote for secession, the outcome will be honored by the central government. Conversely, Khartoum may continue to perfect its old habits of undermining agreements, perpetuating the cycle of violence at the great cost of innocent lives, and to the detriment of Sudan as a nation and the whole region of Africa.


Whatever Khartoumís true intentions, the political leadership and population of South Sudan are locked in a countdown to independence, and Sudanís peace partners, which include regional Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD) countries, the troika members (United States, Norway, and U.K) and the international community, are monitoring the current developments and with many uncertainties, are compelled to follow the treacherous journey to 2011.


As the CPA winds down into its final stages, there is a lot of doubt as to whether the internationally acclaimed 244-page document that ended the one of Africaís longest conflicts will survive the challenge of time, or make the list of ďSouthern Sudan: too many agreements dishonored.Ē





© Copyright by SudaneseOnline.com

Please feel free to send us your Articles , Analysies news and press releases to [email protected]

Top of Page

This report does not necessarily reflect the views of Sudanese Online.com

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Articles and Analysies
  • Political Divorce a lesson for both the Sudan and the rest of Africa.By: Justin Ambago Ramba
  • China has been silent about the war in Darfur in order to reap the benefits from Sudanese oil and the sale of Chinese weapons to the Sudanese government by Jaafar Mirmar
  • Sleeping with the Devil:When the US goes the wrong way in Sudan by Ibrahim Ali Ibrahim -Washington, DC
  • South Sudan is never too young for an independent state By Atok Dan Baguoot
  • Making Justice is a Political pinyana in south Sudan. By: Daniel Abushery Daniel
  • A letter to UN Secretary General by Dr. Mohamed Ali Mustafa
  • Kiir Promises Clean Water while the Food continues to come from Uganda. By: Justin Ambago Ramba
  • Why Egypt Threatens the Africans over their own Water By Izzadine Abdul Rasoul
  • Let the Debate Boil Down to the ReferendumÖ Not a Dead Unity!! By: Luk Kuth Dak.
  • No Negotiation with Al-Bashir Government even if the venue is in white House By: Abdellatif Abdelrahman
  • NCP: End this Ignoble Episode By Usman Ibn Foda-CRID, Abuja
  • Idriss Deby, The Ultimate Hater of South Sudanese! By: Luk Kuth Dak.
  • To Salva Kiir: Donít Fuel Athorís Rebellion By Dr. James Okuk
  • Why NCP blackmails the AU, UN Forces in Darfur?By : Abdellatif Abdelrahman.
  • A Tougher Obama is needed to secure a Peaceful Divorce in Sudan. By: Dr. Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • Lam Akolís Flunkies Are His Worst Enemies!! By Luk Kuth Dak:
  • Dr. Josephine Laguís case exposes the nasty face of tribal politics in south Sudan. By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • Should Padang-Dinka community continue silent over Jongeli incident? By Atok Dan Baguoot
  • Why Dr. Lam Akol Shouldnít Be The Minister Of Foreign Affairs!! By: Luk Kuth Dak.
  • The Not Inevitable War in Sudan: Goss vs. NPC By: Dr. Mohamed N Bushara
  • Agarís snub on south Sudanís independence must cease. By: Justin Ambago Ramba.
  • Scandalous Pipes Market Disaster or the Ponzi scheme in El-Fasher By Mahmoud A. Suleiman
  • Is American policy over Sudan invidious? By Izzadine Abdul Rasoul
  • An Independent South Sudan Is Vital to USA!! By Luk Kuth Dak
  • Letís SPLM Political Bureau be answerable to all current messes in the South By Atok Dan Baguoot
  • How bitter the injustice suffered, south Sudan must still come first. By: Justin Ambago Ramba.
  • Panaruu-Dinka historical, political naivety and leniency towards the SPLM by Atok Dan Baguoot
  • Western Equatoria: The will to resist and succeed. By: Justin Ambago Ramba.
  • Sudan Elections 2010: Defective beyond repair! By Arman Muhammad Ahmad
  • A Unified Sudanese Currency II by Abdel - Halim Anwar Mohamed Ahmed Mahgoub
  • voting in election is hallmark of demcracy by Siddik, Nadir Hashim
  • The Rigged Elections Boxes Should Be Disqualified By Dr. James Okuk
  • General election of Sudan By Aru Mayan:
  • Nasir Declaration was a well calculated move to destroy the Nuer tribe by Simon R. Gatluak,
  • the manifesto of the Sudanese Emancipation United Movement (SEUM) by Aguer Rual
  • When confusion steps in, then only a genuine change can help. By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • Letís your vote not throttle the CPA By Atok Dan
  • Watch out; is your transport fee to your voting centre available? By Atok Dan Baguoot
  • Delaying the Election is not a Good Option by Nhial K. Wicleek lives in Canada.
  • Are Independent candidates still SPLM members? I doubt BY: Isaiah Abraham, JUBA
  • The SPLM Party Is The Answer: By: Luk Kuth Dak.
  • Dose general Scott Gration Understand get lost? by Hatim Elmedani*
  • SPLM Tactics of Scaring Away Voters in Southern Sudan By Dr. James Okuk
  • Civil liberty must precede the civil divorce. By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • Seeking Justices for the Rape Victims of Terekeka.By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • Will the National Election in Sudan takes place? By Federico Vuni
  • Southerners have better reasons to vote for H.E Salva Kiir Mayardit By: Gieth A. Dauson
  • Dr. Lam Akol SPLM-DC candidate reveals early defeat in Sudan April elections By Magdelina John
  • National Interest first By Kenjok D, Bentiu
  • Kiir declares the Central Equatoria State votes as insignificant! By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • Go to Hague! by Hatim El-Medani
  • Vote for Salva, Vote for Change, is it a Joke? Nhial K. Wicleek lives in Canada
  • President Kiir and VP Machar campaign rally in Bor, Jonglei is historic BY: Mawut Guarak , NEW YORK , USA
  • Watch out SPLA/M by Dr. Mawien Akot is a family physician in Wynyard, Canada.
  • Rushing or NOT, the CPA ends in 2011, IGAD reiterates! By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • Medical Registrars threatening to go on strike over pay increase by By Federico Vuni
  • Your vote may land us into trouble! By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • The Future Of South Sudan Will Be Brighter Than Others Think! By: Luk Kuth Dak.
  • Opinion Poll on nominees for South Sudan Government by Shean Ashang
  • GOSS Corruption: Minister Awut Deng stops recruitment of diplomats BY: David Joseph Lomoro, JUBAs
  • Lam Akol set to meet his Waterloo By Majok Nikodemo Arou
  • Stop the Humanitarian Blockade of Jebel Marra, Darfur BY Dr. Anne Bartlett
  • Who is best leader for South Sudan after April? By DJames Okuk
  • Southerners have Perfected Political Hypocrisy and are becoming vendors.By: Justin Ambago Ramba, MD.
  • (JEM) has not intended to keep the Fellow Combatants out of the Darfur Peace Process By Mahmoud A. Suleiman