Camel Domestication History Challenges Hebrew Bible Narrative by Tarig Anter

Camel Domestication History Challenges Hebrew Bible Narrative by Tarig Anter

08-09-2017, 03:51 PM


Post: #1
Title: Camel Domestication History Challenges Hebrew Bible Narrative by Tarig Anter
Author: Tarig Anter
Date: 08-09-2017, 03:51 PM

03:51 PM August, 09 2017

Sudanese Online
Tarig Anter-الخرطوم-السودان
My Library
Short URL

Domesticated Camels Came to Israel in 930 B.C. Centuries Later Than Bible Says

[The dromedary, or one-humped camel is mentioned in the Bible 47 times. Stories about the Jewish patriarchs—Abraham, Joseph, and Jacob—include descriptions of camels as domesticated animals. For example, Genesis 24:11 says, "And he made his camels to kneel down without the city by a well of water at the time of the evening, even the time that women go out to draw water."]

[Newly published research by two archaeologists at Tel Aviv University in Israel shows that camels weren't domesticated in the eastern Mediterranean until the 10th century B.C.—several centuries after the time they appear in the Bible.

While there are conflicting theories about when the Bible was composed, the recent research suggests it was written much later than the events it describes. This supports earlier studies that have challenged the Bible's veracity as a historic document.

The biblical angle wasn't the focus of the recent research, though, just an after-the-fact observation. The study, published late last year in Tel Aviv: Journal of the Institute of Archaeology of Tel Aviv University, concerned the introduction of domesticated camels at copper smelting sites in Israel's Aravah Valley.]

Source: Richard Dawkins Foundation

[The dromedary was probably first domesti­cated in southern Arabia around 3000 B.C.
Of the estimated 17 million camels of the world, 15 million are one-humped, and the vast majority of these (12 million) are found in Africa, especially in the five neighboring East African countries of Somalia (5.4 million), Sudan (2.9 million), Djibouti (0.4 million), Ethiopia (0.9 million) and Kenya (0.5 million). The rest are mainly found in Asia.]


Camel Domestication History Challenges Biblical Narrative, Bible and archaeology news, By: Noah Wiener date: 02/07/2014

[“And for her [Sarai] sake he [Pharaoh] dealt well with Abram; and he had sheep, oxen, male donkeys, male and female slaves, female donkeys, and camels.”
— Genesis 12:16
Camels play a major role in the Biblical narrative of the patriarchs; the animals are mentioned over 20 times in Genesis alone. However, a recent publication by Tel Aviv University (TAU) archaeologists Erez Ben-Yosef and Lidar Sapir-Hen suggests that camels were not domesticated in Israel until the end of the 10th century B.C.E. This would place Israel’s first domesticated dromedaries during the period of the United Monarchy, centuries after the Genesis narratives. An American Friends of Tel Aviv University news release suggests that “this anachronism is direct proof that the text was compiled well after the events it describes.”]
For the full article go to The Biblical Archaeology Society

Most probably the dromedary, or one-humped camel, was first domesticated in East Africa which had the largest population and oldest population; and from there it went to Arabia while trading with Yemen.

This issue provides one more evidence about the lack of historicity of the Hebrew Bible and the Old Testament. When tales fail to provide a single scientific evidence for more than 3400 years this is the strongest proof that they are fiction made out of thin air.

There are a lot of logic and common sense in new hypotheses to replace the falsehood of the present narrative working against corrupt and ignorant churches, politics, and academia and surly truth will prevail.
Abraham went to Egypt and he didn't notice the Pyramids!; large population of nomadic herders surviving in a desert like Egypt!; wandering in Sinai 40 years!; no records in Egypt who recorded even the number of cats!; staying for 430 years without leaving a single grave!, or borrowing both ways between languages!; failing to identify a single Egyptian king they lived under his rule during 4 centuries! and much more.


The Old Testament must not rely on the Hebrew Bible because it is clearly unreliable and written with political intentions and goals. The Hebrew Bible is definitely not a book of faith, truth, history, or holy.
The Refuge of Israelite 1876 -1476 BC is most probably was in Abyssinia (ancient Ethiopia) and not Kemt (ancient Egypt). And, the Exodus was across Bab-el-Mendab "the Gate of Grief/Sorrows" and not across Sinai.

This will make the ancient Israelite pure Yemeni Arab tribe. It will also challenge the story that Abraham was born in Ur, Mesopotamia (ancient Iraq). This will also cast doubt about the claims which state that the Arabs and Israelite are Semitic, while the Canaanite were Hamitic. But the most important doubt is on the Biblical legitimacy of the modern State of Israel.

Surly The Abyssinian Refuge hypothesis is much more logical and closer to the truth than the The conventional Egypt hypothesis, and The Arabia only hypothesis.

Also, I invite you to read some related articles and follow, and publish, any of my articles at: .....( Tarig Anter, Globalization Threats to Healthy Democracy; Re-Design Democracy and Expose Western Liberal Democracy)

http://3ddemocracy.wordpress.com 3D Democracy (for People Participation in Alternative System; Reinvent Democracy by Creating Three Dimensional 3D Democracy) .....(Modern Ghana) .....(in Arabic) (Tarig Anter, Globalization Threats to Healthy Democracy; Re-Design Democracy and Expose Western Liberal Democracy)

Best regards
Tarig M. M. K. Anter, Mr.

أبرز عناوين سودانيز اون لاين صباح اليوم الموافق 09 اغسطس 2017

اخبار و بيانات

  • علي عثمان محمد طه: داعش معركة فكرية أدارها الغرب
  • العثور على جثة طفل سنكات في بورتسودان وتوقيف القاتل
  • إبراهيم غندور: محامون أمريكيون خفّضوا غرامة ضحايا التفجيرات لملياري دولار
  • فصل 19 طالباً ومقتل وإصابة 24 شرطياً في الأحداث لجنة برلمانية تستدعي أبو كشوة حول أحداث بخت الرضا
  • العثور على أشلاء لجثة طفل بورتسودان المختطف
  • انقطاع بث الإذاعة والتلفزيون القومييْن بسبب قطع الكهرباء

    اراء و مقالات

  • الإنتخابات الكينية : ذاكرة العُنف وصعوبة الإختبار بقلم فيصل الباقر
  • ذرائِعيّة المهدي بقلم عبد الله الشيخ
  • بلد المليون دجال..!! بقلم عبدالباقي الظافر
  • موت وطن !! بقلم صلاح الدين عووضة
  • حماس بين شهادة الأعداء ونكران أولي القربى بقلم الطيب مصطفى
  • تحديات ونماذج : من البيئة الى الدويم!! بقلم حيدر أحمد خير الله
  • الحل ليس في الحل يا هؤلاء بقلم نورالدين مدني
  • إنكسار آمال .. !! - بقلم هيثم الفضل

    المنبر العام

  • Qatar, no prior visa for 80 nations
  • لماذا لانعقد المؤتمر الدستوري بالخارج؟
  • فيديو فاحش وقبيح
  • نداء لكل علماء وخبراء الوطن لمؤتمر عالمي...
  • بـالـجـد حيّرتنى قبل الاستاذ محمد الامين ... !!! مبالغة
  • أي زول يتكلم عن الشاعرة أماني فليتحمل المسؤولية
  • الى الصحفى هاشم كرار المركز الثقافى البقى دكان عبدالإله ابوسن نحن مابندخلو بمزاجه
  • الى الصحفى هاشم كرار المركز الثقافى البقى دكان عبدالإله ابوسن نحن مابندخلو بمزاجه
  • مدراء قروبات يحذفون عددا من الاعضاء خوفا من المساءلة القانونية
  • طُيُورٌ تجُوسُ في القلبِ
  • الاتجاه المعاكس- ماذا تعني العلمانية بنظر الإمارات؟
  • افراح الزميل عبد اللطيف بكري بمدينة العين
  • جمرُ الغِواياتِ
  • بالأمس انقطع تيار الكهرباء عن الإذاعة والتلفزيون لمدة ساعة كاملة مما سبب هلعا فى الشارع السودانى
  • بـــــــيــــــــــان هــــــــــام
  • أعلي الجمال تغار منا
  • يا جماعة هل كلام الجزيرة دا حاصل فعلا في الإمارات ؟؟
  • هل صحيح تم تنفيذ حكم الإعدام في الضابط المسئول عن قتل عوضية عجبنا؟
  • real madrid vs man united super cup
  • مشكلة حروف الجر
  • بيان هام من وزارة الداخلية والجوازات السعودية وقرارات هامه وخطيره للوافدين
  • شكرا الصادق اسماعيل

    Latest News

  • Al Mahdi case: ICC Trial Chamber VIII to deliver reparations order on 17 August 2017
  • Unamid appoints new head, coordinates exit strategy
  • Deputy Chief of Staff Informed on Preparations of Sudanese Civilian Component for Participation in
  • Civil society supports Port Sudan workers
  • Aboud Jaber: Citizen Security is Red line
  • Part of Sudan’s gold revenues to be allocated to states
  • Speaker to visit Kuwait on invitation by his counterpart
  • Cholera spreads in northern Sudan
  • Al-Baher Receives Invitation to participate in Africa Forum for 2017 in Sharm Al-Sheikh