Title: IGAD: another deadline for peace in South Sudan By Luka Biong Deng
Author: Luka Biong Deng
Date: 04-11-2015, 08:18 PM
08:18 PM Apr, 11 2015
Luka Biong Deng-Juba-South Sudan
My Library at SudaneseOnline
After the disappointing deadline of March 5, the role of IGAD in continuing mediating the South Sudan peace talks came under scrutiny. The question is less about what went wrong with the IGAD-led mediation but rather what lessons we can learn to improve the mediation of the next peace talks.
Recently some non-state actors consisting of civil society, media, women, traditional authorities, faith-based institutions and academia held a meeting in Juba to evaluate the IGAD-led peace mediation. Despite bitter criticism of the poorly managed mediation, the participants recognised that IGAD is the only regional organisation mandated to resolve conflicts in the region.
Given the subsidiarity principle and the geopolitics of the region, IGAD is well situated to continue mediating the peace talks, using a new design of mediation. The participants also agreed to expand the IGAD mediation to include other countries that can add value and have sufficient economic, political, diplomatic and military weight. The meeting also recommended the new mediation to learn from the CPA experience of having one main mediator, accepted by all the parties.
While the participants affirmed the principle of an inclusive process, a multi-process of engaging stakeholders was accepted. This would include direct negotiations between the warring parties, provided that the outcome is brought to the plenary of all stakeholders. The meeting also stressed the added value of the Arusha Agreement in resolving the outstanding issues in the IGAD-led mediation.
With the failure of the peace talks in Ethiopia, the warring parties have started pursuing the option of war, as seen recently by increased violations of the cessation of hostilities agreement. The question is: What can be done to encourage the warring parties to engage in peace talks but in good faith?
A recent report, titled ‘South Sudan: The Cost of War’, indicates that every minute spent on the war effort will make the task of putting South Sudan on the path of sustainable peace and stability more difficult. The report shows that if the conflict continues for another one to five years, it will cost South Sudan an estimated $28 billion. In addition, the region could save up to $53 billion and the international community $30 billion if the war stopped today. The report stressed the urgent need for the warring parties, the region and the international community to take action to bring peace to South Sudan.
A possible action of encouraging the warring parties to conclude peace deal is to enforce targeted UN sanctions on individuals who are obstructing the peace talks. Although these sanctions may target individuals, there is need for a thorough assessment of their impact on the people of South Sudan, the region and the international community. A recent evaluation of the effectiveness of UN targeted sanctions shows that they are effective only in one-third of the time in changing the behaviour of targeted individuals, constraining them from engaging in certain activities or stigmatising them.
UN targeted sanctions are often evaded through the diversion of assets through a third party, the use of black markets or safe havens, the diversification of funds and investments, and reliance on family members. Besides, the report shows that sanctions do have unintended consequences, such as an increase in corruption and criminality, the strengthening of authoritarian rule, a burden on neighbouring states, diversion of resources and a negative humanitarian impact.
Given the complex context of South Sudan, the unintended consequences of UN targeted sanctions will certainly be borne by the people of South Sudan, with far-reaching consequences on their lives and livelihoods. In addition, neighbouring countries such as Sudan, Kenya, Uganda and probably Ethiopia would not be receptive in implementing the sanctions given their economic and security interests in South Sudan and the possible impact of the sanctions on their economies.
Another option for the region is to use the much-awaited report of the AU commission of inquiry to encourage the warring parties to conclude the peace agreement without compromising on issues of justice. Although the content of the report is not known, the leaked report may provide a hint of what is expected from the final report. It is most likely that some senior leaders of the warring parties will be the prime suspects of the atrocities committed since the eruption of the conflict in December 2013.
It is understandable that the release of the report should be managed in such a way not to obstruct the peace talks. Given the fact that the warring parties committed themselves to issue of justice in Arusha Agreement, the African Union in collaboration with IGAD, the Troika, the EU and the UN could use the AU report as a carrot or stick when appropriate in encouraging the warring parties to conclude a peace agreement.
Another option is the leaked IGAD action plan for resolving the conflict in South Sudan by April 18. Unlike previous deadlines, when the warring parties were given a chance to agree on the contentious issues, the new action plan aims at proposing a final and binding peace agreement to be signed by the parties by April 18.
If the leaked document reflects the true IGAD action plan, then the challenge is how to inform this process so that it reflects the aspirations of the people of South Sudan and reduces the risk of bringing a ‘bad peace’. As a good peace is becoming unattainable due to the intransigent positions of the warring parties, the remaining choice for the people of South Sudan is whether to have a bad or imposed peace, or war.
The remaining outstanding issues are two armies, federalism, power-sharing, the choice between the position of prime minister or an additional vice-president, and succession. With the exception of federalism, all these issues are less of concern to the people of South Sudan. The security concerns rightly raised by the SPLM-in-Opposition can be resolved by increasing the pre-interim period, to build trust between the warring parties and establish appropriate security guarantees rather than having two armies.
The issue of federalism is less contentious. It has been agreed in principle as the appropriate system of government for managing diversity in South Sudan. However, its adoption requires a thorough study and engagement of the citizens as part of the constitution-making process. The other issues of power-sharing, the position of prime minister or another vice-president, and succession can either be resolved in the context of the SPLM reunification agreement in Arusha or through logical assessment, as reflected by previous IGAD proposals and its protocol of August 25, 2014.
One would expect the newly expanded IGAD-plus mediation, with South Africa, Rwanda, Chad and Algeria added, to be bold in proposing a draft agreement guided by the overwhelming desire for peace of the people of South Sudan. If the proposed agreement would subject the remaining issues to the will of the people, then it cannot be termed a bad peace. However, it would be appropriate that all the stakeholders, and particularly the warring parties, are given a last chance to discuss the proposed peace agreement before it is signed into a final agreement.
The author is the director of the Centre for Peace and Development Studies at the University of Juba. He is also a global fellow at the Peace Research Institute in Oslo and an associate fellow at the Carr Centre for Human Rights Policy at Harvard Kennedy School. He can be reached on mailto:[email protected][email protected]
Topics related to the subject or the author
Has General Kiir Ever Accomplished Anything?! By: Luk Kuth Dak 04-07-15, 10:19 PM, Luk Kuth DakAN OPEN LETTER TO PATRIOT SOUTH SUDANESE AND SALVA KIIR 03-19-15, 08:24 PM, Zechariah James MacharHOW CAN WE ACHIEVE PEACE IN SOUTH SUDAN by Zechariah James Machar 03-15-15, 06:08 AM, Zechariah James MacharIraq’s heritage and cultural cleansing by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 03-03-15, 06:04 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerAn emergency landing Reasons:normal and weird by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 03-03-15, 06:03 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerAN OPEN LETTER TO PRESIDENT KIIR By: Cde. Sirir Gabriel Yiei Rut 03-03-15, 00:00 AM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutFrom the window of history by Abdul-Aziz Ali Omer 03-02-15, 06:43 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerMaterial Religion by Abdul-Aziz Ali Omer 02-27-15, 03:21 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerWounds of Sarajevo by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 02-25-15, 04:40 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerGange river, the legend and hope by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 02-25-15, 04:35 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerGedaref:memories…dreams and reflections by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 02-24-15, 01:39 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerA message of peace and love by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 02-24-15, 01:38 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerAnts declared the first curfiew by Abdul-Aziz Ali Omer 02-24-15, 01:35 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerWith Gun Sultan Salva Kiir Must Come Down And Face ICC by Sirir Gabriel Yiei Rut 02-23-15, 04:00 PM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutThe collapse of a revolution by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 02-22-15, 06:09 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerSouth Sudan continued to sideline war veterans, wounded heroes and heroines By Cde.Sirir Gabriel Yi 02-20-15, 03:36 PM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutSouth Sudan: A moment for youths to wake up and called for Kiir's exit to quit the throne 02-18-15, 04:59 PM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutUS Deputy Assistant Secretary Visit to Khartoum by Yasir Arman 02-18-15, 02:45 PM, ياسر عرمانNuer- traitors by Ruach Yat 02-17-15, 03:11 PM, Ruach Wal YatWhy the SPLM-IO choose federalism. By: Cde. Sirir Gabriel Yiei Rut 02-10-15, 10:11 PM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutJertig-a Sudanese wedding custom by Abdulaziz Ali Omer 02-07-15, 05:49 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerA new horizon for Sudanese tourism by Abdul-Aziz Ali Omer 02-05-15, 02:38 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerA Comment on El-Affendi’s Article, Mahmoud Taha:Heresy and Martyrdom by Dr. Omer El-Garrai 01-21-15, 03:47 PM, عمر القرايDec 24,marked the darkest days in malakal (1-2) by Gatdiet Peter 12-24-14, 11:45 PM, Gatdiet PeterBrigades for calls and development for votes by Abdul-Aziz Ali Omer 12-08-14, 02:14 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerBetter the Presence of the UNAMID for the Darfuris despite Shortcomings By Mahmoud A. Suleiman 12-04-14, 07:22 PM, Mahmoud A. SuleimanThe Future of Peace and Democracy in Sudan By: Imam Al Sadig Al Mahdi 11-03-14, 04:04 PM, الإمام الصادق المهديWill Sudan’s al-Bashir follow the example of Compaoré in Burkina Faso By Mahmoud A. Suleiman 11-01-14, 05:41 AM, Mahmoud A. SuleimanA call for worldwide Mourning demonstration by Zechariah James Machar 10-24-14, 04:10 PM, Zechariah James MacharRe: Sudan and Ebola virus epidemic by Hussein Sa’ad 02-01-15, 05:09 AM, بكرى ابوبكرRe: Al-Zaidi bird by Omer Ahmed طائر الزيدي تأليف ورسم: عمر دفع الله 02-02-15, 06:22 PM, بكرى ابوبكرBeyond Conflict in South Sudan by Dr. Ahmed Hamoda H. Fadlalla 09-29-14, 01:22 PM, Ahmed Hamoda H. FadlallaMadina Bor in Bor By Martin Garang Aher 09-29-14, 01:17 PM, Martin Garang AherTime has not yet come for foreign troops to leave the country!By/ Mayor Angong Panther 09-29-14, 01:02 PM, Mayor Angong PantherIGAD, South Sudan need Kiir to be a Ceremonial President! By: Sirir Gabriel Yiei Rut 09-28-14, 02:24 PM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutDevelopments in South Sudan Conflict: Is it not overdue for the 3 envoys to dismount and go home? 09-24-14, 09:13 PM, مقالات سودانيزاونلاينIGAD; from peace mediators to peace destructors 09-24-14, 09:08 PM, Michael Gatguat TapAN APPRECIATION LETTER and ALTERNATIVE TO WIN PEACE BACK TO SOUTH SUDAN 09-15-14, 09:58 PM, Peter Riek NguanyThe travesty of the IGAD peace process for South Sudan By Amir Idris 08-31-14, 06:36 PM, Amir H. Idris45 days of IGAD are strategies to waste the rainy season By: Sirir Gabriel Yiei Rut 08-27-14, 10:44 PM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutIGAD SHOULD DISMISS RIEK MACHAR FROM ADDIS ABABA/Gordon Buay 08-25-14, 04:54 PM, Gordon BuayGood citizens make for good leaders By: Sirir Gabriel Yiei Rut 08-23-14, 04:52 PM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutRESPOND TO JONGLEI STATE’SD/GOVERNOR BABA MEDAN’S EMPTY THREATS. By Sirir Gabriel Yiei Rut, 08-11-14, 03:29 AM, Sirir Gabriel Yiei RutSudan, s tyranny rolls back from its own initiative of national dialouge)) by Adaroub Sedna Onour 06-01-14, 11:32 AM, Adaroub Sedna OnourCivil war in south Sudan will affect economic investment to neighboring countries especially Ethiop 05-14-14, 08:44 PM, Ruach Wal YatIt is vital to.Clear up the mess first... Before national consensus in Sudan 05-07-14, 02:23 PM, Adaroub Sedna OnourA TALE OF TWO VISITS by Mr Mark Simmonds MP, UK Minister for Africa 04-29-14, 06:41 PM, مقالات سودانيزاونلاينSudan Revolutionary Front (SRF) Road Map to Comprehensive Political Settlement in Sudan 04-25-14, 06:22 PM, الجبهة الثورية السودانيةNassir is stronghold central power Naathhoods since 1982, 1991, and 2013 by Ruach Wal Yat 04-19-14, 07:46 PM, Ruach Wal YatAl-Bashir's Futile Decree 158 Fell short of Demands of Sudanese who are ahead to oust him 04-16-14, 04:43 PM, Mahmoud A. SuleimanWhy I am opposed to IGAD's role to mediate peace By: Gatkuoth Lok 03-30-14, 05:48 PM, Gatkuoth LokA salute to Sudan and condolence to China By: Abdulaziz Ali Omer 03-10-14, 04:23 PM, Abdul-Aziz Ali OmerCall for proposals: IGAD, Civil Society Drylands, Facility (27 March) 03-10-14, 04:08 PM, سيف اليزل سعد عمرSouth Sudan crisis: Will the peace last? 02-04-14, 07:13 PM, Ahmed Hussain Adam‘Madina’ Bor in Bor By Martin Garang Aher 01-19-14, 05:03 PM, Martin Garang Aher Beyond Conflict in South Sudan by Dr. Ahmed Hamoda H. Fadlalla 01-12-14, 07:21 PM, Dr. Ahmed Hamoda H. Fadlalla Understanding the Suicidal War in South Sudan Translated from the Fren 01-10-14, 05:14 PM, SudaneseOnline South Sudanese Civil war rise up under Salva Kiir Mayardit, and result 12-31-13, 07:17 PM, Ruach Wal Yat South Sudanese Civil war rise up under Salva Kiir Mayardit, and result 12-31-13, 07:17 PM, Ruach Wal Yat Negative Ethnicity: A Threat to Any Peace in South Sudan By: Adeeb Y 12-25-13, 06:36 AM, Adeeb Yousif F.Tribute to Professor John L Cloudsley-Thompson 11-06-13, 05:49 AM, Thomas Tewfik George Janjaweed Leader Hilal and his Search for a new Tribal War in Darfur 09-18-13, 04:05 PM, Abdullahi Osman El-Tom Janjaweed Leader Hilal and his Search for a new Tribal War in Darfur B 09-15-13, 07:11 PM, Abdullahi Osman El-Tom