Voice of the unheard & home to the homeless
Front Page  عربى
المنبر العام
 Latest News
 Articles and Analysies
 Press Releases
 Photo Gallery
 About Sudan
  Sudanese Music
  Sudanese Links
  Discussion Board
  2006 News Archives
  2006 Articles Archives
  2006 Press R.Archives
  2005 News Archives
  2005 Articles Archives
  2005 Press R.Archives
  PC&Internet Forum
  Poll System
  Tell A Friend
  Upload Your Picture
  Contact Us


Articles and Analysies الصفحة العربية Last Updated: Feb 13, 2011 - 7:24:29 AM

Non-Odious Debts and South Sudan Independence Challenge By Dr James Okuk

Email this article
 Printer friendly page
Follow sudanesewebtalk on Twitter

Non-Odious Debts and South Sudan Independence Challenge


By Dr James Okuk


This article is a critique of an excellent article written by James Alic Garang on September 27, 2010, titled “Odious Debts: The Sole Reason to Renege Repayment upon Secession,” and on a projection on the fate of South Sudan economy when the independence becomes the order of the days at the end-road of the full implementation of the Comprehensive peace Agreement (CPA). But Garang’s article failed to ask and answer an important question: what was the motive of what he categorized as the “odious debts” of the Sudan, which is almost becoming a stumbling block on post-referendum negotiations in preparation for South Sudan Independence after 2011?


Recalling the visit to Juba in the first week of September 2010 of the World Bank Vice President for Africa Region, Ms Obiageli Oby Ezekwesili, I have resorted to a position of supporting the issue of the discussed debts without shipping in extremism. It may look un-strategic to tell Khartoum and the North that Juba and the South shall have nothing to do with them once South Sudan becomes independent on 9th January 2011 if the CPA flight managed to land well on a smooth ground. The above-mentioned mentioned former Nigerian Minister – the lady who exactly looks like a gentlemen on the face – affirmed to government authorities in Juba that the World Bank will speed up membership for South Sudan in that international monetary management institution with quick relieve of its debts once the acclaimed independence becomes reality on the ground recognizable worldwide.


Now, given this assurance, should we not play the game in a cool manner and by avoiding extremism of total rejection of the debts share with Northerners? If the World Bank has promised South Sudan to this extent, should it not look wise not to worry about the debts anymore since they are going to be swiftly erased? Should the SPLM not accept willingly and quickly the share of the debts from the North since it will end up as no-debts once South Sudan becomes an independent state? Should we not worry much of the first things first; i.e., how to achieve our independence which is already a granted condition for relieving our part of international debts, be they odious or non-odious? I think the issue of debts comes second to our quest for independence and there is no need to complicate this with refusal to repay the said part of the debts share. With no much doubt, the rejection might hinder the independence of South Sudan. Again, it is strategically crucial to know our priorities, sine qua non.


Even if we accept Garang’s argument that the money the Sudan is indebted with was used to harm Southerners, it will also bet true that a critical question might be raised: had not the people of Southern Sudan rebelled against the Sudan Government, there wouldn’t have been any need to borrow huge money internationally to buy arms and other military necessities of conducting the war against the rebels so that they don't overrun the government by capturing towns and forming a parallel government of their own in the same country. In other words, it could be argued that the war in the Sudan has never been a one-sided affair otherwise there wouldn’t be anything called clash, conflict or devastation at all in Southern Sudan.


Brother Garang allegory of "an itchy-fingered, rich and adversarial younger brother who stole some cows from the neighboring cattle camp", is a bit problematic with one-sidedness of the issue because he didn't bother to ask: why did this "rich adversarial younger brother" chose to go out and steal some cows from the neighbor? Remember the philosophical wisdom that says "everything even the chance itself have a reason for being". Our rebellion in the South cannot be denied as part of the reasons for our "rich and adversarial younger brother" in the North to get those debts, right?


Thus, metaphorically speaking too, and with acknowledgement that the North had stolen the cows, yet it should not be the only one alone to pay the consequences of stealing those cows because the South was part of the motive for stealing; the rebellion and the duty of government to contain it. Have it not been argued that the GoSS has the right to deal with any rebellion in Southern Sudan because it is its duty as a government to protect the land and the people within its jurisdiction? If the GoSS can buy heavy arms for the SPLA and police forces for this purpose, should we disown them in future for having borrowed money for the purpose of dealings with the rebels or invaders of South Sudan? Was it not the threats from those rebels and invaders that became the motive of spending huge amount of public monies (including borrowing) on these arms for the sky the land and the water? Surely, it was, and the rebels should not escape the responsibility of repaying the debts when they happened to reach peace deal with the government and become part of government or the whole of it.


It is never strange that the issue of international debts is not an issue of justice, par excellence, because after all there is no fairness in the Algebraic calculus of accumulating the debts by adding constant interest rate, which is so highly killing than the debts itself. The suffering we are encountering now cannot be ruled out as the result of greed of the Western systems of banking and loans. So, let us accept these international imposed debts on us willingly in order to secure our independence first, and nothing else but the first things first.


Debts Are Non-Odious if:

(1)    They were borrowed for reasons though without improving the living conditions of those for whom they were borrowed for. Yes, Khartoum can show destruction in Southern Sudan as an outcome of these debts but with a justification that it was for carrying out the government duty of crashing rebellions? Even the US and other Western countries have gone as far as Afghanistan and Iraq to shun the terrorist’s threats to their governments and nations at home. That is why the Bush’s wars have been inherited by the successor and are now called Obama’s wars.

(2)    They were borrowed on behalf of people who cannot be asked for consent since they (these people) didn't recognize the government that ruled their country. In other words, they are debts created in the interest of the state even if it is a regime’s state. It is not the National Islamic Front (NIF)'s regime— which incurred have incurred alone the said debts because the civil war in the Sudan started long before they took over the government of the county; they must not shoulder all these debts.

(3)    The creditors willingly made deals with the corrupt and anti-civilian government but on a basis that they are a government, any how. They lent to the governments of the Sudan even though they knew the nature of the regimes because, after all, they were governments with attorney powers to act in the name of the people, in ruling a country with embassies run by Ambassadors and diplomats from other countries.


This approach, though non-radical, is new. No country did it before even the Latin American countries that intentionally defaulted many of their debts in 1990s but have remained fragile to the date, except Brazil, Argentine, Chile and Mexico. The so-called Highly Indebted Poor Country (HIPC) initiative came out of the need for debt relief but with strings to keep the old colonial masters on the high table at UN and other international arenas. Quite a number of Sub-Saharan African countries are beneficiaries of this program today but on condition of keeping the feet-licking of the colonial masters. At the moment, the Sudan is not part of the HIPC but South Sudan might speedily becomes one, given what the World Bank have promised in Juba this year. Even the African Development Bank, the regional leading lender on the continent now, does not lend to the Sudan but gives aid in the form of Multi-Donor Trust Fund (MDTF) with intention of launching the lending scheme in future. After all the banking system of this so-called African bank is never African but Western and unfair as well.


Yes the Sudan’s debts owed to international lenders are close to US$ 38 billion, one third of which is interest rate. No doubt, Khartoum shall have its way and Juba shall take half with Southern Sudan walking out of negotiation table with US$ 19 billion of debts. In 2010, Southern Sudan public sector budget was $ 2 billion. “Assume this budget figure remains constant for the next five years. Expressing the external debt as percentage of the annual budget, we arrive at 950%. This literally means, for every one dollar Southern Sudan government budgets for its day-to-day operations, it approximately owes ten dollars to its creditors." Very bad!!!


But here you can see how the so-called world's money lenders are very oppressive to the poor nations even when they acknowledge the high level of poverty in those countries. They lend much money in order to take away the little that those poor nations have in hands. I think Osama Bin-Laden and his Al-Qaeda followers have the right to become terrorists to the West and their oppressive financial and economic systems to the point of bombing the Twin Towers of the World Trade Centre in New York City on September 11, 2001 if what President Ahmedinejad of Iran said at the UN General Assembly in September 2010 was not correct.


In conclusion, Southern Sudan will not be abusing the doctrine of non-odious debts. We have every proof to show the debts had served to protect the government and the land of the Sudan and some of its people who did not take up arms against Khartoum and its successive regimes. The creditors were aware of this. Thus, the South should accept to take some debts from Khartoum, and should later lobby hard to get the grant of the World Bank promise during the visit of the Vice President for Africa Region to Juba, because such debts were not odious in the first place as there is a reason to build a new nation on the mountain of debts created out of rebellions. Working to relieve these debts on our part is the surest way to alleviate the external debt burden on the new nation to be born. After all there is no creditworthiness in those debts because the creditors can never be fair even when the indebtors become the IMF darlings with white rose. The Bretton Woods’ system of monetary managements have not been yet liberated from neo-colonialism tendencies in international economic sector, and we have nothing to do now but to accept being the perpetual prey of these predators.


Dr James Okuk is reachable at [email protected]


© Copyright by SudaneseOnline.com

Please feel free to send us your Articles , Analysies news and press releases to [email protected]

Top of Page

This report does not necessarily reflect the views of Sudanese Online.com

اخر الاخبار
  • الاتحاديون.. فرقة لا تبشّر بوحدة
  • مركز دراسات الهجرة بجهاز المغتربين ينظم منتداه الشهري الثالث عن الحراك السكاني
  • وزير الدفاع:لا أستبعد ضربات اسرائيلية أخرى.
  • ديبي يعلن إنطلاق الإنتخابات الرئاسية في تشاد .. والمعارضة تتوعده بمصير القذافي وبن علي
  • والي الجزيرة يقر ببعض الفساد ويكشف عن تدابير في فضيحة دريم لاند
  • الجنوب كسب براءته العقوبات الأمريكية...الشمال مسلسل فشل رفعها مستمر
  • العدل والمساواة تؤكد سيطرتها على منطقة وادي هور وتنفي تواجد قوات الحكومة بها
  • رئيس حركة العدل والمساواة "القيادة الثورية ":السلام خيارنا الاستراتيجي وعلى أتم الاستعداد للجلوس للتفاوض متى تلقينا الدعوة من الوساطة
  • اعتصام اللاجئين السودانيين أمام مفوضية اللاجئين بالقاهرة
  • مأساة 450 دارفوري عالقين في السلوم خوفا من بطش الأمن السوداني .
  • بروفسور حامد تيجاني:النظام السوداني يسعى بكل قوته لتفكيك الدولة للحصول على شرعية دوليه تمكنه من الاستمرار في القمع والبطش
  • أحمد هارون يشرع في تنفيذ تخصصه : احراق سبعة أطفال وثلاث نساء مسنات داخل بيوتهم
  • ممثل حكومة الجنوب في واشنطن يلتقي الرئيس الكيني
  • الرابطة العالمية بأمريكا تشجب وتدين الهجوم الغادر الذى نفذته مليشيات حزب المؤتمر الوطنى فى قرى بجبال النوبة
  • محلل اقتصادي: تعاون جنوب السودان في مكافحة الإرهاب وراء إعفائه من العقوبات الأمريكية
  • العدل والمساواة ترفض الدعوة الإفريقية لحسم منبر الدوحة نهاية الشهر
  • المحــبوب عبد الســـلام: الأمثل للسودان أن نوحد البرامج ونقربها
  • النائب العام المصري يقرر حبس مبارك ونجليه في اتهامات بالفساد المالي وقتل الثوار
  • جاتكوث يشن هجوما عنيفا على هارون.. ويصفه بالمجرم الهارب من وجه العدالة
  • المحبوب عبد السلام: السودان في خطر والحزب الحاكم فوضوي
  • الحكومة الأميركية تعلن عن أن دولة السودان الجنوبي لن تخضع للعقوبات الإقتصادية الأميركية بعد التاسع من يوليو القادم
  • وصال المهدي: استجوبوه مرة واحدة، سألوه عن اسمه، فقال لهم نسيته!!
  • د.جبريل: رأس النظام إنفصالي من الدرجة الأولى و لن نكتفي بالتنديد حيال إستفتاء دارفور.
  • أكثر من 150 طالب جنوبي يعتصمون أمام مكتب حكومة جوبا بالقاهرة للمطالبة بمستحقات مالية متأخرة
  • تباين في الآراء حول صحة الإبقاء على قوات مشتركة مدمجة في أبيي ومناطق البترول
  • ممثل حكومة الجنوب في واشنطن يلتقي وزير الخدمات الطبية والأمين العام للحزب الحاكم في كينيا
  • السفارة السودانية في واشنطن: تقرير الخارجية الأميركية عن السودان غير مهني.. ولا يحتوي على قدر من المصداقية
  • السفير عبدالرحمن سرالختم فى لقاء تنويرى مع الصحفيين السودانيين بالقاهرة
  • وزير الاتصالات وتقانة المعلومات : مشروع الصحة الالكترونية ستتم تبعيته بالكامل لوزارة الصحة الاتحادية
  • تغطية ندوة منتدى التوثيق الشامل للمؤرخ الكبير ضرار صالح ضرار
  • مؤتمر أبناء دينكا تويج ميارديت العالمى الاول ـ ملبورن ـ أستراليا
  • الناطق الرسمي للعدل والمساواة :الحركة ملتزمة بعدم الحركة خارج مناطق سيطرتها.
  • حاكما ولايتي البحيرات وغرب الاستوائية يتوصلان لاتفاق سلام بشأن مايورديت
  • البرنامج الانتخابى للحزب الشيوعى السودانى منظقة جنوب كردفان
  • نيويورك:ندوة عن مستقبل السودان علي خلفية انفصال الجنوب - مطالب الجماهير ونداءات التغيير
  • تنبية هام إلي اللاجئين السودانيين بالقاهرة.
  • زيارة خاصة جداً لأسرة اللواء المعتقل تلفون كوكو
  • استكمالاً للانفصال القوات المسلحة تحزم حقائبها في رحلة العودة شمالاً
  • تقرير الخارجية الأميركية عن أوضاع حقوق الإنسان في العالم يكشف عن إنتهاكات خطيرة للحكومة السودانية
  • وفد من إئتلاف ثورة 25 يناير المصرية يصل الخرطوم اليوم
  • تقرير حول اللقاء الثاني لرابطة أبناء دار فور و المحكمة الجنائية الدولية بباريس
  • د. جبريل: ماذا سيفعل النظام إن عجز الغرب عن إزاحة القذاقي؟ و للنظام أصابع تنخر في عظام الجبهة الوطنية العريضة
  • نشرة جهاز المغتربين (1) لشهر ابريل 2011م
  • نائب رئيس حكومة جنوب السودان يغادر الى اديس ابابا غدا الاحد
  • لقاء للوطني مع الاقتصاديين يتحول إلى نقد عارم للسياسات الاقتصادية للحكومة
  • صحيفتي (اجراس الحرية) و (الميدان) تعلقان صدورهما احتجاجاً علي المصادرة
  • لضبط الحدود الحزام الأمني...تقليل تكلفة المراقبة بحفظ المنافع
  • محمد ابراهيم نقد:السودان (عضمه قوي) ولن (يتفرتق) إذا قامت ثورة شعبية
  • في عقد قران السيد المحجوب الميرغني : كتب صلاح الباشا من داخل مسجد السيد علي ببحري
  • تعيين اتحاد مؤقت لإدارة شئون كرة القدم في جنوب السودان
  • Articles and Analysies
  • The fallacy of "the New South of the North" by Amir Idris
  • U.S. Financed Groups Had Supporting Role in Arab Uprisings by Tarig Mohamed Mohamed-kheir Anter
  • Shy U.S. Intellectual Created Playbook Used in a Revolution Tarig Mohamed Mohamed-kheir Anter
  • Gene Sharp and the Theory of Soft and Undercover Coups d’États By: Tarig Mohamed Mohamed-kheir Anter; Khartoum
  • English: Washington Post: Pregressive Faith: Mohammad Ali Salih, Washington
  • Sharing Lessons Learned From Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. By: Luk Kuth Dak.
  • AU Peace and Security Council Communiqué on Sudan is a Disgrace By Mahmoud A. Suleiman
  • Is African Union Peace and Security Council(PSC) is Peace spoiler in Darfur By Tadjadine Bechir Niam
  • A Solar Energy Market Strategy for South Sudan by Amogpai Ater
  • Jonglei Governor, Kuol Manyang Juuk, should immediately resign from his office!!! By: Daniel Abushery Daniel
  • Darfur patiently licking wounds by Abdelgabar Dosa
  • Missyria Horses Saddled to Defend Abyai by Gibreel Musa Ahmed
  • The Nuba Mountains of Central Sudan has the Right to Self-Determination By Yassir A. Kori, Oklahoma City, Ok – USA
  • The significance of UN Security Council Resolution No. 1973 on Libya and its likely impact on the dire situation of the Darfur Conflict Eight Years on By Mahmoud A. Suleiman
  • Kenya's Equity Bank says bullish about 2011
  • What South Sudan Politicians should consider when discussing boarder issue of South Sudan in the advent of South Sudan independence..By Paul Izaru Bilal.
  • Three-State Solution and a New Sudan: Suggestions for a New Constitution By Jimmy Mulla
  • EXCUSE ME! MAY I OPEN FIRE ON MY OWN PARTY?! By: Daniel Abushery Daniel (USA)
  • Who can convince SPLA/M that development achieves their goals in Abyei better than war by Dr Abdulkarim Gibril Elgoni
  • Higher Democracy Monitoring & Mentoring Organization By: Tarig Mohamed Kheir Anter; Khartoum,
  • Proposed Universal Code of Conduct for Political Parties By: Tarig Mohamed Kheir Anter; Khartoum/ Sudan; Tel.: 00249911636990
  • The Arab League of Shopkeepers! By: Tarig Mohamed Kheir Anter
  • DR LAM’S pre-NEW YORK STORY! By Peter Aban Mujkwan
  • No To Hamas-style Democracy By: Tarig Mohamed Kheir Anter, Khartoum
  • The fighting in Thothim area of the Chollo Kingdom by Peter Karlo
  • The Bogus Humanity of International Community By Izzadine Abdul Rasoul
  • Ghazi Salahaddin the Stealth Spoiler of peace Sabotages the Darfur Peace Talks in Doha By Mahmoud A. Suleiman
  • “I had a dream” about Abyei (1) by Dr Abdul-karim Elgoni
  • Watch out for Khalifa Al Thani Islamic Global Caliphate By: Tarig Mohamed Kheir Anter
  • The challenges of the new Republic of South Sudan!! By: Luk Kuth Dak.
  • Corruption of Some members of Dinka tribe shouldn't be related to Political Tribalism in South Sudan by Garang Akur
  • Hypocrisy of Sudan’s NCP and double Standards of the Arab Media By Dr. Mahmoud A. Suleiman
  • No to a Pseudo-Islamic REPUBLIC by Badreldin Yousif Dafallah Elsimat
  • All Things Have Fallen Apart by Namaa AL- Mahdi
  • “The new york times” “My Country Divided” by MOHAMMAD ALI SALIH
  • GOSS Cairo office: Corruption of Parmena Mangar and Robert Marial has reached out to Southern Sudanese communities in Cairo. by Lojuan Abdallah
  • An Article On What is Expected from Constitution of South Sudan By Dr. James Okuk
  • International community Deserts Darfur and passes it over to the NCP mercy! By Dr. Mahmoud A. Suleiman
  • The snake doesn't strike twice from the same hole!! By: Daniel Abushery Daniel (USA)
  • Why House Of Nationalities Is Necessary in Souyth Sudan By R. Mou Run