Quick analysis of the tripartite agreement of the E. Nile Basin countries Egypt,Ethiopia and Sudan

Quick analysis of the tripartite agreement of the E. Nile Basin countries Egypt,Ethiopia and Sudan


03-23-2015, 07:43 PM


  » http://sudaneseonline.com/cgi-bin/esdb/2bb.cgi?seq=msg&board=15&msg=1427139825&rn=0


Post: #1
Title: Quick analysis of the tripartite agreement of the E. Nile Basin countries Egypt,Ethiopia and Sudan
Author: Mohamed Salih Mohamed Yassin
Date: 03-23-2015, 07:43 PM

07:43 PM Mar, 23 2015
Sudanese Online
Mohamed Salih Mohamed Yassin-Udine, Italy
My Library at SudaneseOnline



Quick analysis of the tripartite agreement of the East Nile Basin countries Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan on the Great Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) (excluding Eritrea)....



By: Mohamed Salih Mohamed Yassin



Without seeing what the tripartite agreement has stated.....One can assume that it based on the internationally recognized principles of transboundary water resource management....the current major governance treaties of the Nile Basin concerning these three states are the 1929 and 1959 treaties....without considering the under negotiation Cooperation Framework Agreement CFA....these internationally recognizable treaties normally incorporate several internationally recognized transboundary water resources management principles ranging from the principle of equitable and reasonable utilization, an obligation not to cause significant harm, principle of cooperation, information exchange, notification, consultation and peaceful settlement of disputes, and moreover the newly adopted principle of benefit sharing instead of water sharing as per se. These principles generally are fundamental for establishing solid foundation and common ground to plan and promote a sustainable development which is mainly branched in social equity, economic viability, and environmental protection, on basin-wide dimension in our East Basin case.



The Declaration of Principles on the Great Ethiopian Renaissance Dam is an important step which was supposed to be signed before the erection of the dam, not while the project is at its implementation of almost 50 %.....In any case, it is good that Egypt and Sudan came to the cooperation track under the international cooperation and development umbrella. The right of the other Nile Basin states in sustainable development and fair exploitation of their resources remain as one of the major stakes for all without privilege, however, remain the dilemma on the will of Egypt and Sudan join the Cooperation Framework Agreement? This remain also an issue to be cleared and will appear readable once this declaration of principles is made public and embark the implementation stages. Let us bear in mind that there will be other 25 new dams to be erected along the Nile Basin. In particular, South Sudan as a newly born state within the Nile Basin has no any dam for hydropower generation, and it is in deadly and bad need to have such energy security....in addition to that the other Nile Basin states have also the due rights to its sustainable development and energy security which requires also major exploitation of the available resource of which the Nile River is essential.



This declaration of principle on the GERD is said to contain mainly 10 basic principles which are common for most of the trans-boundary river basins.....and the challenge remain in the interpretation and quantification of the needs and the realistic deeds....now Egypt is justifying its vital need for more than the 55.5 BCM of water, as historic right, which is a complex issue, not fully sharable with the rest of the Nile Basin partners....that necessity is critical due to the demographic steady growth of Egypt. This demographic challenge is also the case of the rest of the Nile basin countries which are currently have population totaling more than 560 million inhabitant and projected to reach around 880 million in this century.



Doubtless, this renaissance dam will boost the economic growth and energy security for Ethiopia and the region as it is claimed, and it will jeopardize the functioning of the currently erected dams along the path of the Nile, in addition to that, the socio-economic impacts of this huge infrastructural opera coupled with the expected environmental and ecological alteration will be of huge implications. Negative impacts and implications to be mitigated and adapted for and positive counter and outweighing impacts and implications which are to be harnessed and benefited from in a basin-wide vision.





Worth to mention that the some people inhibiting the Blue Nile Region of Sudan have mentioned that they were held obscured and were not raised participant in these important negotiations which will have huge implications on their livelihood....and they have mentioned that they will have their say when it is appropriate. The lack participatory approach and non transparency are characterizing this declaration of principles.



Once this declaration of principles is revealed to the public, all stakeholders are expected react and will come back to it for deep and detailed discussions and consensus building.





Mohamed Yassin (MY),

23 March 2015

Udine, Italy



Mohamed Yassin is a Sudanese and Italian PhD candidate in Economics, Ecology, Landscape and Territory at the Department of Civil Engineering & Architecture, University of Udine, Italy. He is conducting research works on the Nile Basin food wastage and security, urban waste, and resource management in the Nile Basin.



He is reachable at this address.



Department of Civil Engineering & Architecture,

University of Udine, Italy.

E: mailto:[email protected]@uniud.it

E: mailto:[email protected]@gmail.com

S: Mohamed_Salih_Yassin

T: MohamedSMYassin





Mohamed Yassin
Dept. of Civil Eng. & Arch.
University of Udine
Italy


Topics related to the subject or the author


  • South Sudan Rebel Group Releases Child Soldiers 03-23-15, 07:29 PM, wall street online journal
  • Nine medical students were born in UK and studied medicine in Sudan 03-23-15, 07:20 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Missing British-Sudanese medics had humanitarian motives 03-23-15, 07:13 PM, BBC News
  • Nine British medics enter Isis stronghold to work in hospitals 03-22-15, 00:15 AM, theguardian
  • Egypt’s President visits Khartoum on Monday 03-20-15, 01:12 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Egypt's President directs to review a proposed Nile agreement with Ethiopia and Sudan 03-18-15, 06:50 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan describes the agreement on Ethiopia dam as an important achievement 03-17-15, 09:20 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan’s president invites his Egyptian counterpart to sign a document on the Ethiopian dam 03-11-15, 06:20 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • South Sudan:76 organizations call for publication of AU Inquiry Report as deadline for peace passe 03-06-15, 10:20 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan, Egypt and Ethiopia reach an agreement on sharing of Nile waters and Ethiopian Dam 03-06-15, 02:33 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan’s president urges the parties to overcome differences about the Ethiopian dam 03-06-15, 02:24 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan, Egypt and Ethiopia meet in Khartoum to discuss the Ethiopian dam 03-03-15, 04:36 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Tripartite Commission of the Ethiopian Dam meets in Khartoum 03-02-15, 07:31 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Egypt funds first of several dams in South Sudan 02-26-15, 03:27 AM, Daily News Egypt
  • Egypt never stopped communicating with Nile basin countries: Egyptian Ambassador to Sudan 02-24-15, 03:18 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Egypt, Sudan, Ethiopia receive offers for Nile dam studies 02-23-15, 05:35 PM, Ahram Online
  • Offers from firms to conduct technical studies on the Ethiopian dam 02-23-15, 05:32 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Mass deportation starts at new dam sites in eastern Sudan 02-23-15, 05:32 PM, Radio Dabanga
  • One killed in El Geneina-Zalingei road robbery, Darfur 02-21-15, 04:04 PM, Radio Dabanga
  • Sudan calls for resolving of the outstanding points in Nile Basin Initiative 02-21-15, 04:01 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan denounces beheading of 21 Egyptians by Islamic State in Libya 02-16-15, 04:01 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • USA criticises Sudan for obstructing UN inquiry into mass rape 02-15-15, 03:55 PM, Radio Dabanga
  • Sudan, Egypt and Ethiopia reach an advanced stage on agreement on Ethiopian Dam 02-15-15, 03:54 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan, Ethiopia and Egypt hold an unannounced meeting to discuss Ethiopian Dam 02-13-15, 03:57 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan investigates rape of girl in Darfur by UNAMID officer: Source 02-13-15, 03:49 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan calls for Egypt to return to the Nile Basin Initiative 12-30-14, 01:37 AM, SudaneseOnline News
  • We would not allow any malicious activity against Sudan: Egypt's Foreign Minister 12-07-14, 02:02 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudan says obstacles about construction of Ethiopian Dam is overcome 12-01-14, 01:30 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Egypt, Ethiopia, Sudan tripartite talks end with agreements 08-27-14, 04:34 PM, Daily News Egypt
  • Egypt rejects adjournment of “Renaissance dam” negotiations 07-23-14, 10:17 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Expert: Renaissance Dam does not pose danger on Sudan and Egypt 05-20-14, 08:00 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Political researcher from root cause conflict between indigenous tribes in south Sudan 05-05-14, 02:36 PM, Ruach Wal Yat
  • Sudanese President: Sudan is first beneficiary from of development in Ethiopia 04-29-14, 03:22 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Parliamentarians describe as “vague” FM stance toward Halayeb 04-16-14, 07:02 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Egyptian 'suspicions' behind Ethiopia dam crisis: Sudan FM 04-10-14, 08:26 PM, TurkishPress
  • Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood leader visits Khartoum 04-05-14, 02:56 PM, The Middle East Monitor
  • Egyptian chargé d'affaires: Sudan is still studying impact of renaissance dam 03-23-14, 06:12 PM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Sudanese ambassador in Cairo describes as not true supporting Muslim 02-04-14, 03:58 AM, SudaneseOnline News
  • Egyptian former Irrigation minister: Sudan abandons Egypt for Ethiopia 01-07-14, 03:51 PM, SudaneseOnline News