Title: Prospect of arrests in Darfur case bleak:Fatou Bensouda
Author: Radio Dabanga
Date: 03-31-2015, 04:44 PM
04:44 PM Mar, 31 2015
Radio Dabanga-Amsterdam NL
My Library at SudaneseOnline
March 31 - 2015 THE HAGUE
"More or less, the Darfur case is still on the table," says Fatou Bensouda in the Hague-based ICC on 27 March, 2015 (Radio Dabanga)
Some of the International Criminal Court's resources and staff on the Darfur case are working on other criminal cases since the prosecutor's suspension of investigations into the western Sudanese region last year. The ICC prosecutor claimed the office is able to immediately “pull back” to active investigations into the case against President Omar Al Bashir, among others, if she decides to reverse the suspension. 31 March 2015 marks ten years since the Security Council passed Resolution 1593 that referred the situation in Darfur to the ICC.
International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutor Fatou Bensouda announced the suspension of the investigation into war crimes in Darfur for a lack of action by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) on https://www.dabangasudan.org/en/all-news/article/icc-prosecutor-shelves-darfur-case-for-lack-of-un-support12 December 2014. The hibernation does not mean that the prosecutor's office has abandoned the Darfur case. “In fact, far from it,” Bensouda said in an exclusive interview with Radio Dabanga on Friday, following a statement of the ICC Pre-Trial Chamber II on 9 March. That day, it informed the UNSC about Sudan’s non-cooperation in the arrest of its incumbrent president, and left the council to take the necessary measures it deems appropriate.
Radio Dabanga: Your decision to freeze the investigations into war crimes in Darfur has led to disappointment among many internally displaced people in the region. They raise questions about the suspension because in 2014, fighting and displacement in Darfur continued in large numbers, also according to the UN. And you suspended the case. Why?
ICC prosectuor Fatou Bensouda: “Hibernating the case simply means that the office's activities in Darfur will be limited to monitoring the Sudan situation. And it will not be, for the time being, we will not be conducting active investigations. As we have to prioritise our cases, and also shift our resources to cases that [….] are in fact approached in trial.
“The prospects of arrest [of suspects] in Darfur are very remote. Also the UNSC, who referred the case to us, have themselves shown to be uncommitted to take any action to arrest. So I’m facing an environment here, where the office's resources for investigation are already overstretched. My office was left with no choice but to hibernate investigative activities.
“But I want it to be absolutely clear, really, that the situation has been hibernated does not in any way mean that the office’s abandoning the cases in Darfur.”
Some people in Darfur think you are abandoning them.
“What they think is not correct. We are monitoring the cases but we are not doing active investigations in the new situations. For the moment, if the situation changes for us, I can immediately pull back [to active investigations]... The office remains open to receiving additional information on the situation of Darfur.
“Also, the witnesses [who provided testimonies in the case] have nothing to fear, because as the case is still open, the responsibility to protect the witness remains.”
"We did not have any team ready to take on the case of Dominique Ongwen (LRA) after his surrender."
Comments have been made that the hibernation will eventually lead to stopping the whole case of Darfur. Can the case be separated into pieces for the individuals?
“I completely disagree with that advice that has been given, because what has happened is the case is still a case in my office. […] This is the situation: it is not two cases, it is not three cases, it is one situation. It is the Darfur situation.
“We have issued four warrants, against [President Omar] Al Bashir, against [South Kordofan Governor, Ahmed] Harun, against [former Janjaweed leader] Ali 'Kushayb', and against [Minister of National Defense, Abdel Rahim Muhamed] Hussein. […] also, you remember the case against [Bahar Idris] Abu Garda, against Banda [Abaker Nurain], [Saleh Mohamed] Jerbo...
“How long will we continue to go on investigating and not getting anything, with all the arrest warrants not executed? I have a lot of cases that need attention equally. […] For instance, we had the surrender of Dominique Ongwen [top leader of the Lord Resistance's Army (LRA) in Uganda, taken into custody on 6 January this year in the Central African Republic and appeared before the ICC on 26 January]. We were not expecting this at all. We did not have any team ready to take it. I had to take resources away, including those from Darfur, and put it there to build a team, able to do the case of Ongwen.”
Are you daily monitoring the situation in Darfur?
“Of course. There are people in my office who are still handling the Darfur file. There is a senior trial lawyer in fact, who has been put on that case together with others who are still there. […] But let me clarify to you that the warrants of arrests against Mr Al Bashir and all of them, they remain in place. And I will continue to call for their execution.”
How is the office handling the reported mass rape in Tabit, North Darfur, that happened on 30 November? The rapes of 221 women and girls by Sudanese soldiers have been confirmed by Human Rights Watch in February.
“What I can tell you at the moment is that we are receiving information about this incident. I have to receive information, plus all the reports – everything that I can get from reliable sources – and I will analyse it in my office. Then we will decide on the next steps. If it warns me to reconsider my decision from hibernation to active investigation again, this will be done.”
There may be plans by some countries to invoke Article 16 of the Rome Statute (the founding charter of the ICC), deferral of investigation or prosecution, in the case of Al Bashir.
“I think this has been attempted before, but it was rejected by the UNSC*. If you do not meet [the conditions under Article 16], I do not think the UNSC will grant any deferral. [The criteria for a deferral are that ICC investigations are detrimental to the maintenance of international peace and security, or that suspending the court's activities would contribute to peace in Sudan.] To be clear, deference is for one year. And it may be renewed but it may also not be renewed.”
* The fifteen members of the Security Council have not previously submitted a majority vote for a deferral of an ICC investigation or prosecution. The split in the council has resulted in the turn-down of requests by Kenya in 2011 and in 2013, and the African Union for all sitting African ######### in 2014.
What is your reply to the suggestions that the hibernation of the case is a result of a deal made with Sudan?
“I do not understand how this can be. The case is waiting for an arrest for it to continue before judges. […] We need the cooperation of Sudan. You will recall that Sudan has an obligation on the international law to execute even the warrants on its territory.”
“We cannot continue asking for the arrest warrants to be executed and putting a lot of resources there just sitting, waiting, while nothing is happening.”
Al Bashir still travels from country to country. What can the ICC do against this?
“We do what we can. Sometimes not in an open way, but we do what we can to encourage the countries to make arrests. But you have to remember that again, it is a matter of cooperation. And an obligation on those states to arrest and surrender, especially those states part of the Rome Statute. But this is not happening for mainly political reasons.
“The ICC cannot go and punish a country. What we can do is to go to the UNSC to inform them that there is no cooperation - which we just did recently. Also, we tell the Chamber that Mr Al Bashir is travelling to country X and Y, to contact that country and ask for reasons why they cannot arrest Mr Al Bashir. Unfortunately this is the system. This is the system I know that Mr Al Bashir is pushing
and continues travelling. But I'm certain that one day, there will be a country that will be willing to exercise its obligation under the Rome Statute, and will arrest him.”
What do you believe is the future of the Darfur case at the ICC?
“I want to just send a message to the victims. The victims of mass crimes that are committed in Darfur should not feel abandoned. The recent surrender and transfer of Dominique Ongwen, senior commander in the LRA, into the custody of the court, in the Uganda situation, has a very important message for the Darfur cases. That is that the ICC is permanent and that the ICC is patient. And no matter how long it takes, the perpetrators of mass crimes will ultimately face justice.”
What will you say to the UNSC in the next ICC report, to be expected coming June?
"I have not abandoned the case. That means that I'm receiving information on the situation.I continue to monitor the situation in Darfur and continue to call for he execution of the warrants that have been issued in Darfur. So, more or less, the case is on. It is not off the table. It is still on the table. But […] we cannot continue asking for the arrest warrants to be executed and putting a lot of resources there just sitting, waiting, while nothing is happening.”
Topics related to the subject or the author
The rebel SPLM-N committed sabotage actions in South Kordofan: Sudanese army says 03-29-15, 04:17 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudan rebels claim attack on Habila garrison in South Kordofan 03-29-15, 04:16 PM, Radio DabangaRebels led by Machar announces that the killed 38 government soldiers in Jonglei and Unity states. 03-27-15, 02:44 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsU.S Company fined USD 232.7 mln for transactions with Sudan and Iran 03-27-15, 02:32 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSchlumberger fined $232.7mn for breaking Iran, Sudan sanctions 03-26-15, 03:17 PM, AFP Agence France PresseYemen: ICRC concerned at civilian casualties amid escalating violence 03-26-15, 03:10 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseU.S. calls on South Sudanese parties to resume peace talks 03-25-15, 08:27 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudanese opposition forum denied permit in Khartoum 03-25-15, 06:05 PM, Radio DabangaSudan’s president travels to Egypt to participate in the Arab League summit 03-25-15, 06:02 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsEgypt, Ethiopia, Sudan sign agreement on Renaissance Dam 03-25-15, 00:58 AM, Radio DabangaJoint Statement on the National Dialogue in Sudan by U.S. State Department 03-25-15, 00:55 AM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseSecurity agents thwart anti-election forum in Port Sudan 03-25-15, 00:51 AM, Radio DabangaSouth Sudan Rebel Group Releases Child Soldiers 03-23-15, 07:29 PM, wall street online journalNine medical students were born in UK and studied medicine in Sudan 03-23-15, 07:20 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsMissing British-Sudanese medics had humanitarian motives 03-23-15, 07:13 PM, BBC NewsSudan plans to disband camps in secure West Darfur 03-22-15, 05:28 PM, Radio DabangaSudan’s ruling party denies use of the State resources in its electoral programmes 03-22-15, 04:19 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsNine British medics enter Isis stronghold to work in hospitals 03-22-15, 00:15 AM, theguardianWFP Executive Director visits South Sudan 03-21-15, 06:09 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSouth Sudan warlord offers abducted boys sit exams - UN envoy 03-20-15, 04:49 PM, ReutersPopulation Under Pressure in South Sudan Opposition Territory 03-20-15, 03:26 PM, Voice of AmericaChina supplies South Sudan with weapons to protect its oil fields 03-20-15, 03:18 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSouth Sudan rebels say civil war will go on 03-20-15, 01:21 PM, AFP Agence France PresseNtaganda case: Trial Chamber VI recommends holding the opening of trial in DRC; decision to be made 03-19-15, 05:15 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitAFRICAN FUEL DEMAND KEEPS GROWING DESPITE ADVERSE CONDITIONS SAYS CITAC AFRICA REPORT 03-18-15, 10:27 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseSudan: ICRC appeals for funds to scale up humanitarian action 03-18-15, 07:13 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsAl Bashir pardons five JEM-Sudan convicts 03-18-15, 05:09 PM, Radio Dabanga500, 000 dollars from FAO to support agriculture in Sudan 03-18-15, 05:03 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsFive dead, three injured in Darfur shootings 03-17-15, 07:36 PM, Radio DabangaChina describes its relationship with Sudan as a model must be followed 03-17-15, 07:33 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudanese popular and official delegations conduct dialogue with U.S. lobbies on sanctions 03-17-15, 07:24 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsAl-Bashir discusses with Mufti of Croatia position of Muslim minorities 03-16-15, 05:08 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsCall for Sudan to stop recruiting minors in South Kordofan 03-16-15, 05:05 PM, Radio DabangaSPLM-N leadership: Sudan Deserves a New Peace 03-15-15, 08:27 PM, الحركه الشعبيه لتحرير السودان شمالSpecialist shortage sees cancer rise in Sudan 03-13-15, 04:22 PM, Radio DabangaSouth Sudan’s government says it does not want ‘Troika’ countries to be included in the peace talks 03-13-15, 04:20 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsForeign aid goods for sale at Sudanese markets: displaced 03-13-15, 04:18 PM, Radio DabangaICC knows it doesn't scare Sudan at all: Information Minister says 03-13-15, 04:15 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSustainable fisheries project launched for Sudan’s Red Sea State 03-13-15, 02:31 PM, Radio DabangaSudanese army says it repels SPLM-N attack on Southern Kordofan 03-13-15, 02:28 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudan’s ruling party welcomes Berlin Declaration 03-11-15, 06:16 PM, Radio DabangaICC moves intended to disrupt the elections: Sudan’s parliament 03-11-15, 06:14 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsNorway and UNIDO launch a € 4,8 million project for the sustainable management of marine fisheries 03-11-15, 05:05 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseS. Sudan Braces for Sanctions as Economy Limps 03-11-15, 05:04 PM, Voice of AmericaICC Trial Chamber I joins the cases concerning Laurent Gbagbo and Charles Blé Goudé 03-11-15, 04:58 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitSix new judges sworn in today at the seat of the International Criminal Court 03-11-15, 03:09 AM, ICC Public Affairs UnitSudan’s ruling party thanks German for sponsoring the Berlin Conference 03-10-15, 04:51 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsChina calls on the warring parties in South Sudan to reach a settlement 03-10-15, 04:49 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsWorld Bank is to address Sudan’s problems in the areas of development 03-10-15, 04:49 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsInternational court: Sudan has failed to cooperate in al-Bashir case 03-09-15, 04:13 PM, ReutersPre-Trial Chamber II informs the United Nations Security Council about Sudan’s non-cooperation in t 03-09-15, 03:54 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitThe Secretary-General Remarks at the opening session of the Commission on the Status of Women 03-09-15, 03:50 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseOn International Women’s Day, ICC reaffirms commitment to end sexual and gender-based crimes 03-08-15, 08:06 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitUS condemns lack of "political leadership" to resolve South Sudan's war 03-07-15, 05:08 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudan’s President participates in the Egypt Economic Development Conference 03-07-15, 05:03 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsOngwen case: Confirmation of charges hearing postponed to 21 January 2016 03-06-15, 10:34 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitSix newly elected ICC judges to be sworn in on 10 March 2015 03-06-15, 10:32 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitSouth Sudan:76 organizations call for publication of AU Inquiry Report as deadline for peace passe 03-06-15, 10:20 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsLubanga case: ICC Appeals Chamber amends the Trial Chamber’s order for reparations to victims 03-04-15, 04:10 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitStatement attributable to the Spokesperson for the Secretary-General on the South Sudan Peace Proce 03-04-15, 03:48 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseUNAMID announces that it will cut 770 civilian jobs 03-02-15, 07:36 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsChina sees no "logic" behind US-drafted resolution on South Sudan 02-28-15, 03:19 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudanese tribesmen request reconciliation mechanism 02-28-15, 03:18 PM, Radio DabangaSudan’s president stresses the opposition’s inability to block the elections 02-28-15, 03:17 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsFatou Bensouda, following the Appeals Chamber decision upholding the acquittal in the Ngudjolo Chui 02-27-15, 09:53 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitNgudjolo Chui case: ICC Appeals Chamber confirms the acquittal decision 02-27-15, 07:30 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitSudanese leader says being hounded by ICC, West 02-27-15, 07:29 PM, AFP Agence France PresseFatou Bensouda, at a press conference in Uganda: justice will ultimately be dispensed for LRA crime 02-27-15, 07:25 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitLiberation of Kuhliyat garrison 5 km west Kadugli city 02-25-15, 08:33 PM, الحركه الشعبيه لتحرير السودان شمالBashir: Iranian centers closed to protect Sudan 02-25-15, 08:32 PM, Al Arabiya NewsStatement of the ICC Prosecutor at a press conference in the Central African Republic 02-25-15, 08:29 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitSudan’s Main Opposition Parties to Boycott April Election 02-25-15, 05:58 PM, Voice of AmericaUS presents UN draft resolution on imposing sanctions in South Sudan 02-25-15, 05:55 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsChina announces that it will continue to support South Sudan peace process 02-24-15, 04:04 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsThree die in militia attacks in South and North Darfur 02-24-15, 04:03 PM, Radio DabangaSudan and Kuwait negotiate help Zain repatriate $280 million worth of Sudanese pounds 02-24-15, 04:02 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsDarfur displaced invite US Deputy Secretary of State to visit their camps 02-24-15, 04:00 PM, Radio DabangaBoko Haram on agenda of IGAD Inter -Parliamentary Union in Khartoum 02-23-15, 05:29 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudan activists to take action against Tabit mass rape 02-23-15, 05:29 PM, Radio DabangaDarfur rebels kill soldiers in central Jebel Marra 02-21-15, 03:23 PM, Radio DabangaDarfur authority stresses that improvement of U.S-Sudanese relations will bring peace 02-21-15, 03:22 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsCentral Darfur's displaced without shelter after fire 02-21-15, 03:21 PM, Radio DabangaSudan’s president addresses the Speakers of Parliaments of IGAD 02-21-15, 03:19 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsBrig. Gen. John Mabieh vowed to take Malakal town by 9th March this year 02-19-15, 03:38 PM, Weirial Puok BaluangSouth Sudan Rebel Spokesman Defects 02-18-15, 11:43 PM, Voice of AmericaU.S. Treasury Allows Personal Communication Exports to Sudan 02-18-15, 11:41 PM, wall street online journalFAO teams up with the Ministry of Livestock, Fisheries and Rangelands and provides about USD 1 mill 02-18-15, 03:41 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseSouth Sudan Warns Media Not to Publish Rebel Interviews 02-17-15, 04:29 PM, Voice of AmericaSudanese journalist disappears under mysterious circumstances 02-15-15, 03:57 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsPolitical delegation in Tabit scares residents 02-14-15, 03:16 PM, Radio DabangaIGAD's Inter-Parliamentary Union convenes its meeting in Khartoum 02-14-15, 03:12 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudan’s opposition welcomes HRW’s confirmation of Darfur mass rape 02-13-15, 01:58 PM, Radio DabangaSudan refers the case of the two political detainees to the court 02-13-15, 01:56 PM, SudaneseOnline News38,600 displaced in Darfur in a month: OCHA 02-13-15, 01:54 PM, Radio DabangaSudan security detains man at North Darfur market 02-13-15, 01:48 PM, Radio DabangaStatement of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Fatou Bensouda, on the Internation 02-12-15, 03:17 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitSeven Investment Programme Areas Under the Sudanese National Agricultural Investment Plan (NAIP) Id 02-12-15, 03:15 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseSLM-SR statement in response to ICC Chief Prosecutor Suspension of Darfur Investigations 02-08-15, 06:47 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseSudan and Arab League discuss providing assistance to Darfur 02-04-15, 05:00 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsStatement of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Fatou Bensouda, ahead of the gener 02-02-15, 07:56 PM, ICC Public Affairs Unit400 JEM faction combatants to merge with Sudan army 02-02-15, 04:36 PM, Radio DabangaMore bombs fall on Golo, Central Darfur 02-02-15, 03:43 PM, Radio DabangaSudanese court renews detention of opposition leader 02-02-15, 03:41 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudanese El Midan gagged for 10th time 02-02-15, 03:40 PM, Radio DabangaUSAID, BRAC Launch Project to Reach Out-of-School Children in South Sudan 01-30-15, 05:29 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsAfrica Union Peace and Security Council stands in the way of Justice in South Sudan 01-30-15, 05:27 PM, SudaneseOnline Press ReleaseFormer Sudan Lost Boy Becomes Chess Master in NYC 01-30-15, 04:46 PM, Voice of AmericaRe: Sudanese-Chinese talks convened today in Khartoum 01-30-15, 02:56 AM, بكرى ابوبكرEthiopia supports the collective leave of African States from (ICC): Sudan’s government says 12-26-14, 02:57 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudan demands apology for Jordan statement on ICC report 12-23-14, 10:04 PM, The Middle East MonitorLetter to the UN on the ICC sent today:Re the ICC arrest warrant for President al Bashir 12-22-14, 03:29 PM, بيانات سودانيزاونلاينSudan calls on (UNSC) to cancel resolution 1593 which referred the Darfur file to ICC 12-19-14, 02:06 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsICC’s referral of Darfur issue to UN is a means of pressure to arrest those wanted by the court: Su 12-17-14, 02:44 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsDisplaced urge UN Security Council to act on Darfur case 12-16-14, 04:29 PM, Radio DabangaICC decision is a “chance” to Sudanese and African community to put an end to the court: Sudan’s Pa 12-15-14, 02:26 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsAl-Bashir says (ICC) is one of the tools aims to humiliate and subjugate Sudanese 12-14-14, 01:41 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsICC criticizes UN for failing to push for the arrest of Sudanese President 12-13-14, 03:10 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsThe Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Fatou Bensouda, attends 7th Colloquium of Inter 11-05-14, 05:58 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitICC holds first sub-regional Seminar of Counsel and the Legal Profession in Dakar, Senegal 10-27-14, 09:41 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitFatou Bensouda briefs the United Nations Security Council 10-24-14, 04:31 PM, ICC Public Affairs UnitHead of Sudanese Alliance puts road-map plan to remove tension 06-18-14, 07:32 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsSudan renews rejection to ICC measures 06-18-14, 07:32 PM, SudaneseOnline NewsStatement of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Fatou Bensouda, providing an updat 03-07-14, 06:42 PM, SudaneseOnline Press Release